Blog | Subscribe | Free Trial | Contact Us | Cart | Donate | Planned Giving
Log In | Search
facebook
rss
twitter
  • CURRENT
    • Fall 2022 PDF
    • SUMMER 2022 ARTICLES
    • NEWSworthy: What’s Happening and What It Means to You
    • Blog
    • INSISTING ON LIFE
    • Pastoral Reflections
    • About Us
    • HLF In The News
    • LIBERTY TO DO WHAT? Hadley Arkes and Rusty Reno join George McKenna June 1, 2022 in New York
  • DINNER
    • GREAT DEFENDER OF LIFE DINNER 2022
    • HOST COMMITTEE Great Defender of Life Dinner 2022
    • Great Defender of Life 2022 Dinner Ticket
    • Great Defender of Life 2022 STUDENT or PREGNANCY CENTER STAFF Ticket
    • DINNER JOURNAL ADVERTISING 2022
  • ARCHIVE
    • Archive Spotlight
    • ISSUES IN HTML FORMAT
  • LEGACY
    • Planned Giving: Wills, Trusts, and Gifts of Stock
  • SHOP
    • Cart

NEWSworthy

What's Happening and What it Means to You
2 Comments

CA Adopts TX-Law Model That Could Hurt Pregnancy Centers

14 Dec 2021
Edward Mechmann
Governor Gavin Newsom, pregnancy centers
Print Friendly, PDF & Email
The law of unintended consequences is inexorable and dangerous.

Last week, the Supreme Court handed down a decision about the Texas six-week abortion ban. That law was constructed specifically to make it difficult for abortion clinics to challenge the law before it went into effect. Its ingenious method is to ban enforcement by public officials, while empowering private parties to bring suits against abortionists. The Supreme Court partially upheld this mechanism, and allowed the law to remain in effect pending further litigation.

While this has provided good short-term benefits in Texas—abortion clinics are virtually out of business—it has set in motion a process that could hurt prolifers elsewhere.

Yesterday, Governor Gavin Newsom of California announced that he wanted his state to adapt the Texas model to allow private citizens to sue manufacturers and sellers of “assault weapons.” Like the Texas law, Newsom’s bill would allow parties to collect fines of $10,000 per violation from their targets, as well as legal fees. The obvious intent is to scare people off from trying to sell these types of guns.

This bill wouldn’t ordinarily seem relevant to prolifers. But it comes on the heels of Governor Newsom’s plans to make California an abortion “sanctuary” if the Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade. That could include paying for travel and lodging for women traveling to California and paying for the abortion itself. The advocates for the bill also want the state to go after pregnancy centers for allegedly misleading information. Earlier this fall, New York’s governor also said she wanted to take “aggressive action” to make the state a “safe harbor” for abortion.

Aside from the troubling concept of an “abortion sanctuary state,” the danger is that pro-abortion states will combine these two initiatives to suppress the rights of prolifers to offer non-abortive options and support to pregnant mothers.

Many jurisdictions, including California and New York City, have already tried to impose notice and signage rules on pregnancy centers that would have forced them to promote abortion. Limits on prolife advocacy and prayerful witness outside abortion clinics have also been passed in many places. Some politicized attorneys general have filed suits to enforce these laws, but of course their resources are limited.

But the Texas model would allow anybody to enforce these laws. The effect could be devastating. Prolifers would be rightly afraid that they could be sued by anyone at any time, with the looming threat of ruinous fines as well as legal fees. Pregnancy centers could be put out of business for even the most technical violations of stringent signage laws. Religious groups such as the Sisters of Life could be penalized for not explicitly disclosing that they don’t refer for abortions. Radical abortion advocates, who are already trying to forcefully suppress the presence of prayerful witnesses at clinics, could use this to scare off sidewalk counselors and witnesses completely.

The law of unintended consequences frequently means that short-term benefits are offset or outweighed by long-term damage. The news out of California suggests that this is precisely what is happening as a result of the Texas law. To prepare for these possibilities, prolifers have their work cut out for them.

394 people have visited this page. 1 have visited this page today.
About the Author
Edward Mechmann

Edward Mechmann is an attorney and Director of Public Policy for the Archdiocese of New York.

Social Share

  • google-share

2 Comments

  1. Pingback: The Human Life Review Unpacking the Latest Ruling on TX Heartbeat Law  - The Human Life Review

  2. Pingback: The Human Life Review Oklahoma House Passes Its Heartbeat Act - The Human Life Review

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Comments will not be posted until approved by a moderator in an effort to prevent spam and off-topic responses.

*
*

captcha *

Get the Human Life Review

subscribe to HLR

Recent Posts

Minnesota passes one of nation’s most permissive abortion laws

01 Feb 2023

Hit and run violence after Roe: Can't we talk about the morality of abortion?

28 Jan 2023

Abortion activist attempts to expose crisis pregnancy centers—and fails

17 Jan 2023

CURRENT ISSUE

Anne Conlon Anne Hendershott B G Carter Brian Caulfield Christopher White Clarke Forsythe Colleen O’Hara Connie Marshner David Mills David Poecking David Quinn Diane Moriarty Dr. Donald DeMarco Edward Mechmann Edward Short Ellen Wilson Fielding Fr. Gerald E. Murray George McKenna Helen Alvaré Jane Sarah Jason Morgan Joe Bissonnette John Grondelski Kristan Hawkins Laura Echevarria Madeline Fry Schultz Maria McFadden Maffucci Mary Meehan Mary Rose Somarriba Meaghan Bond Nat Hentoff Nicholas Frankovich Patrick J. Flood Peter Pavia Rev. George G. Brooks Rev. Paul T. Stallsworth Stephen Vincent Tara Jernigan Ursula Hennessey Victor Lee Austin Vincenzina Santoro W. Ross Blackburn Wesley J. Smith William Doino Jr. William Murchison

Pages

  • Issues
  • Human Life Foundation Blog
  • About Us
  • Free Trial Issue
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  • Planned Giving
  • TOPICS
  • GREAT DEFENDER OF LIFE DINNER

Follow Us On Twitter

Tweets by @HumanLifeReview

Find Us On Facebook

Human Life Review/Foundation

Search our Website

Contact Information

The Human Life Foundation, Inc.
The Human Life Review
271 Madison Avenue, Room 1005
New York, New York 10016
(212) 685-5210

Copyright (c) The Human Life Foundation.