Archbishop Joins Lawsuit Against New York’s MAID Act
New York Archbishop Ronald Hicks and Catholic health care ministry ArchCare last month joined several Catholic religious sisters in a lawsuit against New York’s new assisted-suicide mandate. The religious liberty law firm Becket is acting as their legal representation in the case.
New York’s Medical Aid in Dying Act, signed into law on February 6, took effect on August 5. The act allows terminally ill adults, 18 years and older, with a prognosis of six months or less to obtain medical aid in ending their own lives.
The lawsuit against the MAID Act was spearheaded in mid-July by Bishop John Barres of the Diocese of Rockville Centre, Catholic Health, and four religious communities dedicated to the care of the terminally ill: the Carmelite Sisters for the Aged and Infirm, the Dominican Sisters of Hawthorne, the Missionary Sisters of St. Benedict, and the Little Sisters of the Poor. These religious communities have served the ill and infirm for decades with kindness and charity, rooted in the understanding that every life has value, no matter how challenging or how short.
The MAID Act is in direct conflict with the religious beliefs of these Catholic communities, who filed the lawsuit on the bases that they may be coerced to promote assisted suicide by offering information to terminally ill patients, aiding them in qualifying for lethal drugs, and connecting them with providers to fulfill prescriptions. Not complying with these procedures may lead to devastating fines, loss of professional licenses, and even jail sentences.
With New York’s cooperation, a federal court order was issued on July 30 preventing the state from enforcing suicide regulations against the plaintiffs while the suit is in progress. In joining the lawsuit, Archbishop Hicks is seeking the same protection for all Catholic health care providers in his archdiocese. “As Catholics, we are guided by the compassion of Jesus to serve those of every background who are in need of healing,” the Archbishop said. “We refuse to allow New York to force us to harm the very ones we’ve been called to care for.”
A major health care organization that entered the lawsuit with Archbishop Hicks is New York’s Catholic health care ministry ArchCare. In addition to hospitals, home services, nursing homes, and other services, ArchCare’s Calvary Hospital in the Bronx is the only fully accredited acute care hospital that offers exclusive care and comfort to adult patients with life-limiting illnesses.
According to NBC, Governor Kathy Hochul strongly supported the MAID Act when it was signed on February 6, saying that it confirmed the “right to bodily autonomy, which includes the right for the terminally ill to peacefully and comfortably end their lives with dignity and compassion.” However, to “end their lives” with “dignity and compassion” is an impossibility in the case of suicide. There is no dignity without respect, and disregard for one’s own life, or the life of another, is an act of disrespect not deserving the description of dignity.
Mark Rienzi, president of Becket, observed that “New York is forcing sick and dying people to consider suicide at their lowest moment, regardless of whether they ask for it or not.” To tempt someone in a vulnerable moment is not compassion; it is fraudulent. Calling it compassion would be the same as attributing that virtue to the old women in Arsenic and Old Lace. True compassion is walking alongside the sufferer, loving him, affirming that he is not alone. To assist someone in taking her life is to affirm that she is alone, unwanted. That is a torment far greater than any physical disease.








