Blog | Subscribe | Free Trial | Contact Us | Cart | Donate | Planned Giving
Log In | Search
facebook
rss
twitter
  • CURRENT
    • Winter 2025 PDF
    • WINTER 2025 HTML
    • THE HUMAN LIFE REVIEW HTML COLLECTION PAGE
    • NEWSworthy: What’s Happening and What It Means to You
    • Blog
    • Pastoral Reflections
    • About Us
  • DINNER
    • GREAT DEFENDER OF LIFE DINNER 2024: NEW MEDIA ADDED!
    • Great Defender of Life 50th Anniversary Dinner Ticket 2024
    • Great Defender of Life 50th Anniversary Dinner TABLE for TEN Ticket 2024
    • Great Defender of Life 2024 Young Adult / Pregnancy Center Staffer Tickets
    • HOST COMMITTEE Great Defender of Life Dinner 2024
    • DINNER JOURNAL ADVERTISING 2024
    • ARCHIVE: GREAT DEFENDER OF LIFE DINNER 2023
  • ARCHIVE
    • Archive Spotlight
    • ISSUES IN HTML FORMAT
  • LEGACY
    • Planned Giving: Wills, Trusts, and Gifts of Stock
  • SHOP
    • Your Cart: Shipping is ALWAYS Free!

BLOG

Much work to do, Many minds to change.
0 Comment

“A Conversation on Roe v. Wade”—Encounter Books Panel Discussion

Christopher White
roe v. wade
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

On November 18th, Encounter Books hosted “A Conversation on Roe v. Wade,” a panel discussion focusing on Clarke Forsythe’s highly acclaimed book, Abuse of Discretion: The Inside Story of Roe v. Wade. Readers of the Human Life Review are likely to recall that Forsythe was honored with this year’s Great Defender of Life Award (along with Kristan Hawkins of Students for Life) and his book got a great review from Kathryn Jean Lopez in the Fall 2013 issue [http://humanlifereview.com/booknotes-the-inside-story-of-roe-v-wade/].

Joining Mr. Forsythe on the panel were Charmaine Yoest (President of Americans United for Life), Fr. Gerald Murray (Pastor of the Church of the Holy Family in Manhattan), Mollie Hemingway (Senior Editor of The Federalist), and myself. Perhaps I’m biased, but to me the evening provided one of the more thoughtful, well-reasoned considerations of the present state of the pro-life movement—a testament to Forsythe’s carefully and thoroughly researched book, which set the tone for the evening.pic_related_111413_SM_How-Roe-Happened-Clarke-Forsythe-Book_0

The main argument of Abuse of Discretion is this: When the Supreme Court first agreed to hear Roe v. Wade, the justices had intended to rule only on procedural questions; they certainly didn’t set out to settle the question of abortion rights in America. Then, due to retirements and deaths on the Court, a new configuration of justices decided to strong-arm the others and use the case (and its companion, Doe v. Bolton) to champion the cause of legalized abortion.

But here’s the real clincher: The primary contention used to justify the Court’s decision—that abortion is safer for women than pregnancy and therefore must be readily available—was based on bad science. This subject motivated much of our discussion.

Both Forsythe and Yoest were quick to note that we’re still reeling from the false claim that abortion is good for women—until it is soundly rejected, justices, politicians, and voters will continue to insist that abortion is a social good worth promoting.

I brought up the idea that Roe v. Wade has fundamentally changed the way we think about medicine. Enshrining abortion as a right encouraged people to think that medicine, traditionally intent on healing the sick and curing maladies, could be put at the service of personal desires and lifestyle preferences. Our understanding of healthcare has been perverted by a mindset that weakens medicine’s commitment to doing no harm, and encourages other assaults on human dignity, such as embryonic-stem-cell research, third-party reproduction, and physician-assisted suicide.

Fr. Gerald Murray highlighted the great role of ultrasound imaging in evidencing the scientific fact that life begins at conception. He also spoke movingly about how post-Roe generations have adopted “a survivor’s mentality,” knowing that in light of “choice,” every born human being has escaped the horrors of abortion.

Mollie Hemingway, who moderated the discussion, spoke of the tired language of pro-abortion-rights activists like Katha Pollitt, whose new book, Pro: Reclaiming Abortion Rights, defends abortion as “a moral good.” Hemingway—who, readers might recall, was one of the loudest media voices bringing much needed attention to Kermit Gosnell’s butchery—did a fine job of showing how the likes of Pollitt are fighting a losing battle trying to make abortion attractive. Anyone who is in need of evidence, she reminded us, should reflect on the failed political campaigns of Sandra Fluke and Wendy Davis and Mark Udall, whose overblown “war on women” rhetoric was rejected by voters of both sexes.

As thoughtful as our panel discussion was, and as powerful a contribution as Abuse of Discretion is to the pro-life cause, the evening concluded with a sober reminder that there remains much work to be done and many more hearts and minds to change. That’s why I’m hopeful that conversations like ours will help sow the seeds of eventual conversion.

223 people have visited this page. 1 have visited this page today.

Social Share

  • google-share

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Comments will not be posted until approved by a moderator in an effort to prevent spam and off-topic responses.

*
*

captcha *

Get the Human Life Review

subscribe to HLR
The-Human-Life-Foundation
DONATE TODAY!

Recent Posts

IVF: The Frozen Sleep Evading Time

07 May 2025

Report: "The Abortion Pill Harms Women"

05 May 2025

New York Pushes Asissted Suicide

30 Apr 2025

CURRENT ISSUE

Alexandra DeSanctis Anne Conlon Anne Hendershott Bernadette Patel Brian Caulfield Christopher White Clarke D. Forsythe Colleen O’Hara Connie Marshner David Mills David Poecking David Quinn Diane Moriarty Dr. Donald DeMarco Edward Mechmann Edward Short Ellen Wilson Fielding Fr. Gerald E. Murray George McKenna Helen Alvaré Jacqueline O’Hara Jane Sarah Jason Morgan Joe Bissonnette John Grondelski Kristan Hawkins Madeline Fry Schultz Maria McFadden Maffucci Marvin Olasky Mary Meehan Mary Rose Somarriba Matt Lamb Nat Hentoff Nicholas Frankovich Peter Pavia Rev. George G. Brooks Rev. Paul T. Stallsworth Rev. W. Ross Blackburn Stephen Vincent Tara Jernigan Ursula Hennessey Victor Lee Austin Vincenzina Santoro Wesley J. Smith William Murchison

Shop 7 Weeks Coffee--the Pro-Life Coffee Company!
Support 7 Weeks Coffee AND the Human Life Foundation!
  • Issues
  • Human Life Foundation Blog
  • About Us
  • Free Trial Issue
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  • Planned Giving
  • Annual Human Life Foundation Dinner

Follow Us On Twitter

Follow @HumanLifeReview

Find Us On Facebook

Human Life Review/Foundation

Search our Website

Contact Information

The Human Life Foundation, Inc.
The Human Life Review
271 Madison Avenue, Room 1005
New York, New York 10016
(212) 685-5210

Copyright (c) The Human Life Foundation.