Blog | Subscribe | Free Trial | Contact Us | Cart | Donate | Planned Giving
Log In | Search
facebook
rss
twitter
  • CURRENT
    • Winter 2025 PDF
    • WINTER 2025 HTML
    • THE HUMAN LIFE REVIEW HTML COLLECTION PAGE
    • NEWSworthy: What’s Happening and What It Means to You
    • Blog
    • Pastoral Reflections
    • About Us
  • DINNER
    • GREAT DEFENDER OF LIFE DINNER 2024: NEW MEDIA ADDED!
    • Great Defender of Life 50th Anniversary Dinner Ticket 2024
    • Great Defender of Life 50th Anniversary Dinner TABLE for TEN Ticket 2024
    • Great Defender of Life 2024 Young Adult / Pregnancy Center Staffer Tickets
    • HOST COMMITTEE Great Defender of Life Dinner 2024
    • DINNER JOURNAL ADVERTISING 2024
    • ARCHIVE: GREAT DEFENDER OF LIFE DINNER 2023
  • ARCHIVE
    • Archive Spotlight
    • ISSUES IN HTML FORMAT
  • LEGACY
    • Planned Giving: Wills, Trusts, and Gifts of Stock
  • SHOP
    • Your Cart: Shipping is ALWAYS Free!

BLOG

2 Comments

How Malta Just Stopped Legalized Abortion

22 Aug 2023
Dr. Miriam Sciberras
President Vella, pro-life law in Malta
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

 

American pro-life attention since June 2022 has focused on the legal status of abortion in the aftermath of the Dobbs decision, removing Roe v. Wade’s straitjacket on states that wanted to protect prenatal life. Fewer people know that during the same period, a similar pro-life fight played out on the Mediterranean island nation of Malta, one of Europe’s last two countries (alongside Poland) that provide substantial legal protection to unborn life.

What happened in Malta is instructive, because it mirrored the pro-abortion playbook around the world, namely, using an extreme case to attack all pro-life legislation. While hard cases may make bad law, they generate good “narratives.”

Malta’s most recent abortion debate started with the case of Andrea Prudente, an American tourist who was 16 weeks pregnant when her membranes ruptured. She was admitted to a Maltese hospital.

The clinicians, per normal protocol, monitored her and her baby, ensuring that at no point was she endangered: Malta has had a zero percent maternal mortality rate for over a decade. Such cases are delicate and take time, and sometimes the fetus survives. There was another case like Prudente’s at the time: The mother was treated, and the baby survived. Prudente, however, chose to be airlifted to Spain and terminated her pregnancy. In Malta abortion is illegal.

Prudente’s case—like the 2012 death of Savita Halappanavar in Ireland, which became a symbol for the pro-abortion referendum that stripped protection for prenatal life from the Irish Constitution—is the latest example of a current twist on an old standby. Prior to Roe, protective pro-life laws were accused of being responsible for unsubstantiated “thousands” of deaths each year. Today, claims that pro-life laws intimidate medical personnel from providing the best active care in miscarriage cases is the new wedge designed to carry all other abortions in its wake. That claim, for instance, underlay a case brought against Texas’s pro-life law that led to an August 4 judge’s decision that the Lone Star State’s medical exceptions were “uncertain.”

Malta’s government succumbed to criticism and international pressure over the Prudente case and promised a review of “abortion law.” The Labor Government sent a bill to “clarify” the law in November 2022. The clarification included language stipulating that abortion be permitted if medical complications “may” endanger a woman’s “health”—language similar to that used in the UK’s Abortion Act, 1967, which was intended to limit the scope of abortion but in fact would become a very permissive loophole.

Pro-life groups in Malta saw the “health” provision as a backdoor way to erode Malta’s pro-life legal safeguards and sprang into action. Life Network Foundation organized broad opposition, including an historic, massive protest on December 4, 2022. Position papers from experts defending the law were drafted and published. Prominent public figures, including former President Marie Louise Coleiro Preca, spoke out. The Catholic Church drafted its own paper, addressed the topic in sermons across the Catholic island, and wrote a pastoral letter to parliamentarians. The Opposition party came out clearly against the abortion amendment. Current President of Malta, Dr. George Vella, stated publicly that he would not endorse the introduction of abortion.

Government plans to enact its abortion bill by Christmas 2022 were derailed and, in June 2023, it reversed course and adopted clear pro-life amendments to the bill, which was signed into law June 30. Those amendments caused an uproar in pro-abortion groups, who thought that abortion was going to be allowed in some instances.

It’s clear that defenders of pro-life laws will increasingly need to address claims that such protective legislation endangers women’s lives by either banning proactive medical treatment in complicated pregnancies and/or chilling physicians from employing such treatment out of fear of legal liability.

Malta has shown that pro-life laws and competent medical care for life-threatening pregnancies are not incompatible. As noted, Malta has not seen a maternal death from pregnancy in over a decade. That said, extreme cases such as this create impressions that are not readily dissipated by fact-based discussion. It’s clear that such arguments are a new front in the war against pro-life laws. In the United States, it’s an argument used against states that try to legislate greater protections of the unborn post-Dobbs.  In other countries—like Malta—it will be an argument to weaken pro-life laws where they remain. Prolifers cannot shy away from addressing these claims, with facts, and empathy.

 

953 people have visited this page. 1 have visited this page today.
About the Author
Dr. Miriam Sciberras

—Miriam Sciberras, who holds an M.A. in bioethics from the University of Malta, is chief executive officer of Life Network Foundation, the leading coalition of pro-life forces in Malta. Their website is https://lifenetwork.eu

Social Share

  • google-share

2 Comments

  1. Forrest K. Wright August 24, 2023 at 6:32 pm Reply

    ??? Why was it made legal to kill a child , before it had a chance to be born . this is another of the Supreme Courts judgements that was wrong , in the first place . But no one said anything . So we are all guilty . The same applies to the Dems. party who stole the last election are still doing the same thing right now . Unless we all repent of our actions we are all going to HELL . It needs to be said till people know right from wrong .

  2. Pingback: How Malta Just Stopped Legalised Abortion – Life Network Foundation

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Comments will not be posted until approved by a moderator in an effort to prevent spam and off-topic responses.

*
*

captcha *

Get the Human Life Review

subscribe to HLR
The-Human-Life-Foundation
DONATE TODAY!

Recent Posts

Pro-life Groups Can’t be Forced to Accommodate Abortions, Federal Judge Rules

14 May 2025

Yonkers Woman Learns Abortion is Not the ‘Quick Fix’ She Thought 

12 May 2025

RFK Jr, Autism, Eugenics--and Pro-Life Silence?

09 May 2025

CURRENT ISSUE

Alexandra DeSanctis Anne Conlon Anne Hendershott Bernadette Patel Brian Caulfield Christopher White Clarke D. Forsythe Colleen O’Hara Connie Marshner David Mills David Poecking David Quinn Diane Moriarty Dr. Donald DeMarco Edward Mechmann Edward Short Ellen Wilson Fielding Fr. Gerald E. Murray George McKenna Helen Alvaré Jacqueline O’Hara Jane Sarah Jason Morgan Joe Bissonnette John Grondelski Kristan Hawkins Madeline Fry Schultz Maria McFadden Maffucci Marvin Olasky Mary Meehan Mary Rose Somarriba Matt Lamb Nat Hentoff Nicholas Frankovich Peter Pavia Rev. George G. Brooks Rev. Paul T. Stallsworth Rev. W. Ross Blackburn Stephen Vincent Tara Jernigan Ursula Hennessey Victor Lee Austin Vincenzina Santoro Wesley J. Smith William Murchison

Shop 7 Weeks Coffee--the Pro-Life Coffee Company!
Support 7 Weeks Coffee AND the Human Life Foundation!
  • Issues
  • Human Life Foundation Blog
  • About Us
  • Free Trial Issue
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  • Planned Giving
  • Annual Human Life Foundation Dinner

Follow Us On Twitter

Follow @HumanLifeReview

Find Us On Facebook

Human Life Review/Foundation

Search our Website

Contact Information

The Human Life Foundation, Inc.
The Human Life Review
271 Madison Avenue, Room 1005
New York, New York 10016
(212) 685-5210

Copyright (c) The Human Life Foundation.