Blog | Subscribe | Free Trial | Contact Us | Cart | Donate | Planned Giving
Log In | Search
facebook
rss
twitter
  • CURRENT
    • Spring 2022 PDF
    • Spring 2022 Articles
    • NEWSworthy: What’s Happening and What It Means to You
    • Blog
    • INSISTING ON LIFE
    • Pastoral Reflections
    • About Us
    • HLF In The News
  • DINNER
    • GREAT DEFENDER OF LIFE DINNER 2021
    • Great Defender of Life 2021 Dinner Ticket
    • SPONSOR a TABLE at the Great Defender of Life 2021 Dinner
    • HOST COMMITTEE Great Defender of Life Dinner 2021
    • DINNER JOURNAL ADVERTISING 2021
  • ARCHIVE
    • Archive Spotlight
  • LEGACY
    • Planned Giving: Wills, Trusts, and Gifts of Stock
  • SHOP
    • Cart

Hot Topic

1 Comment

There’s Something About Jahi

16 Oct 2014
Administrator
Wesley J. Smith
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Readers of the Human Life Review may recall my article on brain death, in which I explained why I believe that properly diagnosed, brain dead—e.g., total brain failure—is dead [http://humanlifereview.com/total-brain-failure-death/].

I still do. But recent events in the Jahi McMath tragedy certainly are relevant to that question. Jahi was declared brain dead last year after she suffered extensive bleeding and cardiac arrest following surgery. When Oakland Children’s Hospital told her mother that life support would cease—as permitted by California law—litigation ensued. A judge forced a settlement in which a death certificate was issued, but Jahi, still connected to medical machinery, was transferred to her mother’s care.

We now know that 13-year-old Jahi has been maintained at St. Peter’s Hospital in New Jersey. Tonsillectomy Brain Dead GirlAs I reported on my “Human Exceptionalism” blog at National Review Online, two internationally respected neurologists have now declared under penalty of perjury that Jahi’s condition has improved. More, they opined that she no longer meets the criteria for brain death. In other words, they believe she is alive [see http://www.nationalreview.com/human-exceptionalism/389564/ucla-neurologist-jahi-alive-awake-wesley-j-smith  and http://www.nationalreview.com/human-exceptionalism/389774/mri-test-proves-jahi-not-brain-dead-wesley-j-smith].

Improvement after brain death—assuming proper original assessment—is unprecedented in the scientific literature. That alone should be enough for a full-blown dispassionate reexamination by the country’s best brain doctors. But a Stanford neurologist, who examined Jahi last December at the request of the judge, isn’t convinced. Indeed, he isn’t even curious about her situation and doesn’t want to take another look. How disappointing [http://www.nationalreview.com/human-exceptionalism/389932/really-stanford-doc-says-no-jahi-life-wesley-j-smith].

That roadblock means that Jahi remains legally dead and her case in legal limbo; the hearing to have Jahi’s death certificate revoked is on hold to see if her lawyer can provide more evidence.

We shouldn’t have to wait. The integrity of the system, the interests of science, and the fate of a little girl demand more information. The case should be reopened. Now.

—A regular contributor to the Human Life Review, Wesley J. Smith is a senior fellow at the Discovery Institute’s Center on Human Exceptionalism and a consultant to the Patients Rights Council.

 

 

326 people have visited this page. 1 have visited this page today.

Social Share

  • google-share

One Comment

  1. Glynis October 19, 2014 at 7:45 pm Reply

    Mr Smith, you really need to stop peddling the bunk about Dr. Fisher. He wasn’t asked by the court to “take another look”. He was asked to review the “evidence” that Dolan presented. You should be faulting those “internationally respected neurologists” for not conducting the correct tests to being with.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Comments will not be posted until approved by a moderator in an effort to prevent spam and off-topic responses.

*
*

captcha *

Get the Human Life Review

subscribe to HLR

Recent Posts

ROE OVERTURNED

24 Jun 2022

Amid Possibility of ‘Roe’ Overturning, Pro-life Centers Face Threats and Attacks

15 Jun 2022

What New York’s “Limited Service Pregnancy Center” Bill Really Represents

14 Jun 2022

CURRENT ISSUE

Anne Conlon Anne Hendershott B G Carter Brian Caulfield Christopher White Clarke Forsythe Colleen O’Hara Connie Marshner David Mills David Poecking David Quinn Diane Moriarty Dr. Donald DeMarco Edward Mechmann Edward Short Ellen Wilson Fielding Fr. Gerald E. Murray George McKenna Jane Sarah Jason Morgan Joe Bissonnette John Grondelski Kathryn Jean Lopez Kristan Hawkins Laura Echevarria Madeline Fry Schultz Maria McFadden Maffucci Mary Meehan Mary Rose Somarriba Meaghan Bond Nat Hentoff Nicholas Frankovich Patrick J. Flood Peter Pavia Rev. George G. Brooks Rev. Paul T. Stallsworth Stephen Vincent Tara Jernigan Ursula Hennessey Victor Lee Austin Vincenzina Santoro W. Ross Blackburn Wesley J. Smith William Doino Jr. William Murchison

Pages

  • Issues
  • Human Life Foundation Blog
  • About Us
  • Free Trial Issue
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  • Planned Giving
  • TOPICS

Follow Us On Twitter

Tweets by @HumanLifeReview

Find Us On Facebook

Human Life Review/Foundation

Search our Website

Contact Information

The Human Life Foundation, Inc.
The Human Life Review
271 Madison Avenue, Room 1005
New York, New York 10016
(212) 685-5210

Copyright (c) The Human Life Foundation.